Could your business survive if a key employee walked out today? Now ask the harder version. Could it survive if you did?
Most owners don't like that question, so they put off succession until it's urgent. When they finally choose, they choose the way most companies hire. The person they like. The person who's been there the longest. The person who reminds them of themselves.
That's the mirror test. You hold a mirror under someone's nose, and if it fogs up, they're hired. It feels safe. It isn't a plan.
Signs you've waited too long
You may not be thinking about succession yet. Your business might be thinking about it for you. Watch for these:
- Certain clients will only talk to you.
- Your vacations get interrupted, every time.
- Decisions wait on your desk until you get back.
- Your best people ask what's next for them, and you don't have an answer.
- You're the only one who knows why things are done the way they're done.
If two or more of those sound familiar, you don't have a succession plan. You have a single point of failure, and it's you.
Instinct isn't a plan
Choosing a successor on instinct alone is an emotional bet on the most important decision you'll make about your business. Your successor inherits more than your title. They inherit your clients, your team and everything you know that was never written down.
When owners ask me about succession, my advice is always the same. Go back to your original goal, but this time, use data to find the right person.
I use four filters, and every candidate goes through all four.
Experience, knowledge and skills.
Values, interests and motivation.
How quickly they learn and apply something new.
How they naturally work.
Filter 01: The Briefcase
The briefcase is everything a person carries with them: knowledge, skills, experience, degrees and certifications. It's where every interview starts, and it should be. If someone is going to be your chemist, they should probably have a degree in chemistry.
But be careful with it. Have you ever seen a resume with a few stretches on it? "I'm an astronaut." You can put anything on a resume.
The briefcase also changes over time. People add to it every year. That makes it the easiest filter to fix and the worst one to rely on alone. You're not hiring resumes.
Filter 02: The Heart
The heart is about values. Does this person share yours? Will they make the same hard calls you would, even when it costs something?
A successor with the right skills and the wrong values will take your business somewhere you never meant it to go, one reasonable-sounding decision at a time.
Ask questions that make values visible:
- Tell me about a decision you made that cost you something but was the right call.
- What would you never compromise on, even to win a client?
- Which of our values would you change, and why?
Filter 03: Cognitive Speed
How fast does this person learn? Your successor will face problems you never faced, in a market that won't sit still.
Learning speed is one of only two things about a person that stay steady over time. The briefcase changes. Learning speed doesn't, so measure it instead of guessing. Then ask yourself the honest follow-up question: do you have time to teach them?
Filter 04: Behavioral Drives
Drives are the other thing that stays steady. They're the needs that shape how a person works: how much influence they seek, how much interaction they need, how fast they want to move and how much structure they want.
Start with the role, not the person. What does running this business, or this team, actually demand? Speed or steadiness? Constant contact with people, or long stretches of focus? Strict standards, or room to improvise? Then look at who fits that naturally. That's exactly what Job Targeting is for.
Here's how we do it. We send a short survey to the people who know the role best, and it builds a picture of the person the role needs. Then we lay each candidate right over that picture and see how close the fit is. It doesn't mean other people can't do the job. It just means some people have a natural tendency to fit right into that role a little more easily, and they ramp up faster when they do.
People can adapt. They do it all day long. I worked with a senior military leader whose natural drives were nowhere near what his role demanded. He told me, "I get up every single day and I fake it." He was good at it, and he knew exactly why he was doing it.
"You can do it. The question is really just why."
I also worked with the owner of a bookkeeping firm who hated accounting. He got the degree because his father told him that's how to be successful in business. Great guy, and his work was always perfect. He was also squeezing himself into a role that didn't fit him, every single day. We started talking about ways to grow the business so he could move into a role that did.
A successor who has to fake the job every day gets mentally exhausted and drained. Sooner or later, it shows.
The handoff: trust, then verify
Choosing is the first half. Letting go is the second half, and it's where most owners stumble.
If you're the kind of owner who says "no one does it like I do," watch yourself here. The first time the work isn't done your way, you'll be tempted to take it back. Every time you quietly finish the details someone else skipped, you teach them that you'll always fix it.
I tell owners in that spot three things:
- Trust, but verify until the relationship is earned. Check in on a schedule, not on a hunch.
- Take the five minutes to run the checklist with them, instead of doing their job for them.
- Don't get sucked back into your old role. You picked a successor so you could do something else. Go do it.
Before any of that, write down what only you know. Start with these:
- Your clients. Who they are, who they trust, what they've been promised and what makes them nervous.
- Your relationships. Vendors, partners, bankers and the people you call when something breaks.
- Your unwritten rules. The way things really get done, as opposed to the way the manual says.
- Your reasons. Why the big decisions were made, so your successor doesn't undo them by accident.
People call this tribal knowledge. Every business has it, and in most small businesses it lives in one head.
If it lives only in your head, it walks out the door with you.
Put your candidates side by side
Take a sheet of paper and draw a table. Four rows: the briefcase, the heart, cognitive speed and behavioral drives. One column for what the role needs, then one column for each candidate.
Fill it in honestly. Anywhere you wrote "I think" instead of "I know," that's where you need data. We put the whole worksheet, with questions for each filter and a handoff plan, in a free guide: The Four Filters for Choosing Your Successor.
If you're developing the next leader instead of hiring one, The Leadership APEX is where we do that work.
Your successor is the last big hire you'll make as the owner. Make it with data.
Questions readers ask
Before you need it. The first step costs nothing: write down what only you know about your clients, your relationships and how things really get done. Then start looking at who could grow into the role.
The Briefcase (knowledge, skills and experience), The Heart (shared values and the hard calls they would make), Cognitive Speed (how fast they learn) and Behavioral Drives (whether their natural drives fit what the role demands).
Not necessarily. Choose for what the role demands, not for who reminds you of yourself. Your own style matters most during the handoff, when you have to lead your successor the way they need to be led.
With a cognitive assessment and a behavioral assessment. Both measure things that stay steady over time, so they are worth measuring instead of guessing.
Mike McCloskey
Founder and CEO of HumanLytics Team. Helping leaders turn people data into a people plan.
More about Mike →